← Story Library

Free AI NSFW Story

The Lucky Catch

The Lucky Catch

Annie and Lori had been best friends since they were kids on the same block, sharing everything from secrets to their long-standing crush on Jimmy, the neighborhood heartthrob with his charming wit and cool vibe. Today, they strolled up to his house expecting to meet Annie's mom Kate, who was tight with Jimmy's stepmom Kelly, but the door was unlocked and the place oddly quiet. "Kate? Kelly? We're here!" Annie called out, her red shoulder-length hair swinging as she pushed inside with her usual confident grin. Lori, her curly brown hair bouncing around her slightly chubby face, followed with a positive smile. "Maybe they're running late—let's just wait inside. Everything will work out!" To their shock, they rounded the corner into the living room and froze: Jimmy stood there completely naked, his hands fumbling uselessly to cover his exposed cock, which twitched under their stares. "Oh my god, Jimmy!" Annie burst out laughing, her eyes scanning him up and down with pure delight and disbelief, while Lori blushed furiously but couldn't look away, both feeling insanely lucky that they—out of everyone—got this view of their forever crush. "Annie, Lori, what the hell? I thought I was alone!" Jimmy stammered, face red as he tried shifting to hide his hardening cock, but it only made things worse. Annie stepped closer, witty as ever: "Looks like someone's happy to see us—don't bother covering that up now, we've already seen everything." Lori added kindly, her voice warm despite the heat in her cheeks, "It's okay, Jimmy, you look amazing. We're not judging; we're actually thrilled!" The tension crackled as Annie's gaze turned entranced, and without hesitation she reached out, her strong hand wrapping around his now fully hard cock. "Let's make this fun," she said, dropping to her knees while Lori watched with a positive spark, both staying fully clothed in classic CFNM power. Annie gave him a teasing blowjob, her mouth hot and wet as she took him deep, making Jimmy pant and sweat, his ass clenching. Lori joined in with encouraging words, "You're doing so well, this is exciting!" as she stroked his balls, her own pussy growing wet and dripping under her clothes from the horny thrill. Jimmy groaned, unable to resist their confident advances, and soon Annie stood, hiking up her skirt to reveal her dripping pussy before guiding his cock inside her, riding him with sharp, witty quips like "Bet you never thought your crush would fuck you like this—feels good, right?" Lori cheered them on positively, touching herself through her clothes as Annie came hard, her walls clenching around him until Jimmy exploded, cum shooting deep while they all panted in sweaty ecstasy. But just as they caught their breath, a car pulled into the driveway.

Want to know how it ends?

This is just the opening chapter. Continue the saga - or write a steamy tale starring you.